Revive an Underperforming Restaurant: A Strategic Guide

Paul Segreto
2 min readFeb 20, 2024

Building upon the insights shared in yesterday’s article, Back to Basics: Strategies for Independent Restaurants today we’ll take a deeper dive into the journey of restaurant ownership — a journey that, for many, oscillates between the highs of culinary success and the lows of operational stress. While the previous discussion laid the foundation for embracing core principles and practices, today’s focus shifts to navigating the tumultuous moments when frustration and stress threaten to overshadow passion and drive. It is precisely at these moments, when the instinct might be to say “f*ck it” and throw in the towel, that a strategic pause and thoughtful reflection can pivot a restaurant’s trajectory from despair to renewal.

Reflecting on the path to date can often illuminate the way forward. Start by cataloging the successes that have punctuated your restaurant’s journey, a crucial step in recognizing the solid foundation upon which your business stands. An objective dive into customer reviews can further refine your understanding, revealing patterns of satisfaction and areas needing attention. This exercise transcends mere analysis; it’s about piecing together the narrative your establishment has woven into the fabric of your community.

Engagement with key stakeholders extends this narrative, offering perspectives that might otherwise remain unseen. Conversations with staff leaders, vendors, respected colleagues, and customers should be approached with an openness to honest, constructive critique. Viewing your restaurant through the lens of an external consultant can uncover valuable insights, highlighting overlooked strengths and pinpointing areas ripe for improvement.

Soliciting feedback is a delicate balance, requiring a willingness to hear not just what is going right but also what may have gone astray. Encourage a dialogue that seeks to rediscover forgotten practices that once contributed to your success, guided by the adage that sometimes we stop doing the very things that made us successful in the first place.

With a clearer picture of where you stand, the stage is set for strategic action. Developing a revised business plan and setting actionable, short-term goals can reinvigorate your team and your business, driving momentum and fostering a renewed commitment to excellence.

This process of reflection, dialogue, and strategic planning is not only crucial for those in the middle of operational challenges but also for restaurant owners considering the sale of their business. Enhancing your restaurant’s appeal, both in terms of operations and physical presence, can significantly impact on its marketability and, ultimately, its legacy.

In essence, the journey of restaurant ownership is an ongoing narrative of resilience, innovation, and recommitment. Building on the foundation of returning to basics, today’s discussion underscores the importance of strategic reflection and engagement in navigating the challenges and seizing the opportunities that lie ahead.

Make it a great day. Make it happen. Make it count!



Paul Segreto

Franchises & Restaurants | Management & Development Consulting | Entrepreneurship Coaching | Visionary Thought Leader | CEO & Founder